Cheesy Pizza Toastie Sandwich

This indulgent pizza toastie transforms ordinary bread into a crispy, cheesy delight that satisfies pizza cravings in minutes. Perfect for busy weeknights or when you need comfort food fast without ordering delivery.

I created this recipe during college when my pizza budget ran dry but my cravings wouldn't quit. Now it's my go-to late night snack that delivers all the pizza flavors without the wait or expense.

Ingredients

• White bread slices: Providing the perfect crispy base for your pizza flavors
• Marinara sauce: Adds that classic tomato tang and moisture to the sandwich
• Mozzarella cheese: Creates that essential stretchy pull when melted properly
• Pepperoni: Brings savory spice and authentic pizza flavor in every bite
• Butter: Creates that golden brown exterior and rich flavor when toasted

Step-by-Step Instructions

Sauce Application:

Spread marinara sauce evenly across one bread slice leaving a small border around the edges to prevent leakage. The sauce should be just enough to flavor without making the bread soggy.

Cheese Layer:

Sprinkle mozzarella generously over the sauce ensuring complete coverage. Fresh mozzarella can be used but should be patted dry first to avoid excess moisture which can make your toastie soggy.

Pepperoni Placement:

Arrange pepperoni pieces evenly across the cheese surface for consistent flavor in every bite. For extra flavor consider briefly microwaving the pepperoni for 10 seconds to release some oils before adding.

Assembly:

Place second bread slice on top and press gently to create a seal. Butter both outer sides completely from edge to edge ensuring no dry spots remain for perfect browning.

Toasting:

Place in preheated toastie machine and close firmly. Cook for approximately 3-4 minutes until exterior is golden brown and cheese has completely melted inside. If your toastie maker heats unevenly flip halfway through cooking.

Serving:

Remove carefully using wooden tongs or spatula to avoid burning yourself. Allow to cool for 30 seconds before slicing diagonally for the most appealing presentation and easier eating.

Pin it

This recipe reminds me of rainy Saturday afternoons with my roommates when we'd create toastie competitions with whatever ingredients we had available. The pizza version always won for its perfect balance of simplicity and satisfaction.

Making Ahead Options

These toasties can be prepared ahead of time and refrigerated before cooking. Simply assemble without buttering, wrap tightly in plastic wrap, and refrigerate for up to 8 hours. When ready to cook, butter the exterior sides and proceed with toasting. This makes them perfect for prepping school lunches or quick workweek meals.

Variations To Try

The basic pizza toastie provides endless opportunities for customization. Try a vegetarian version with bell peppers, mushrooms and olives. For meat lovers add cooked sausage or bacon bits along with the pepperoni. Hawaiian style works beautifully with small pineapple pieces and diced ham. Remember to keep fillings thin and pre-cook any raw vegetables to avoid soggy results.

Pin it

Serving Suggestions

Elevate your pizza toastie experience by serving with a small ramekin of warm marinara sauce for dipping. A simple side salad with balsamic vinaigrette creates balance with the richness of the toastie. For appetizer portions cut into quarters and serve with antipasto skewers for an Italian inspired spread that never fails to impress guests.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What can I use instead of pepperoni?

You can substitute pepperoni with ham, cooked bacon, sliced sausage, or for vegetarian options try olives, mushrooms, bell peppers, or spinach. Any traditional pizza topping works well in this toastie.

→ Can I make this without a toastie machine?

Absolutely! Use a skillet or frying pan over medium heat, pressing down occasionally with a spatula. Cook each side until golden brown (about 2-3 minutes per side). You can also use a panini press or regular sandwich maker.

→ What type of cheese works best?

Mozzarella is traditional for its meltability and mild flavor. Other good options include cheddar, provolone, or a cheese blend. For extra flavor, try adding a sprinkle of parmesan or pecorino romano.

→ How can I make this healthier?

Use whole grain bread for added fiber, opt for low-fat cheese, replace butter with olive oil spray, and add vegetables like spinach, tomatoes, or bell peppers. You can also use turkey pepperoni for a leaner protein option.

→ Can I prepare this ahead of time?

You can assemble the sandwich ahead of time (without buttering the outside) and refrigerate for a few hours. Just butter the exterior right before cooking. For best results and crispiness, cook immediately before eating.

→ What sides pair well with this toastie?

A simple green salad, tomato soup, potato chips, or fresh vegetables with dip complement this toastie perfectly. For a heartier meal, serve with a side of marinara sauce for dipping.