Irresistible Florida Shrimp Pie

Florida Shrimp Pie is a delightful coastal comfort dish that combines the briny sweetness of shrimp with creamy, tangy cheese in a golden, flaky crust. This savory pie makes for an impressive weekend dinner or a special lunch that feels both indulgent and homey. The contrast between the rich filling and the crisp pastry creates a texture paradise that keeps everyone coming back for seconds.

The first time I made this for my family, my seafood-skeptical nephew cleaned his plate and asked for seconds. The pepper Jack adds just enough warmth without overwhelming the delicate shrimp flavor. I've served this at several neighborhood gatherings, and the pie plate always returns empty.

Ingredients and Selection Tips

• Frozen Pillsbury Deep Dish Pie Crust: The ready-made crust saves time without sacrificing quality. Allow it to thaw properly for the best texture.
• Chive-and-onion cream cheese spread: This ingredient is the secret weapon, providing flavor complexity without extra chopping. Look for full-fat version for richness.
• Large eggs: These bind the filling together. Room temperature eggs incorporate better than cold ones.
• Frozen cooked shrimp: Mid-sized shrimp work best; they're substantial without overwhelming. Thaw thoroughly and pat dry to prevent a watery filling.
• Pepper Jack cheese: The mild heat balances the sweetness of the shrimp. Freshly shredded melts more smoothly than pre-packaged.

Step-by-Step Cooking Instructions

Step 1: Prepare the Oven and Pie Crust

The success of this pie begins with proper crust preparation. Place a cookie sheet on your oven's middle rack before preheating to 375°F - this helps conduct heat evenly to the bottom of your pie. Allow your crust to thaw at room temperature for exactly 10-20 minutes - any less and it'll crack, any more and it becomes too soft. Using the tines of a fork, thoroughly prick the bottom and sides in a pattern about 1/2 inch apart, pressing firmly enough to create visible indentations without tearing through. This critical step prevents air bubbles that would otherwise lift your crust during baking. Place the crust-filled pie plate directly on the hot cookie sheet and pre-bake for 9-11 minutes until you see just the slightest hint of golden color appearing.

Step 2: Create the Perfect Filling

In a medium mixing bowl (glass works better than plastic for temperature stability), beat the chive-and-onion cream cheese until it becomes noticeably fluffier and completely smooth - about 2 minutes with an electric mixer on medium speed. Adding the eggs one by one is non-negotiable - each egg must be fully incorporated before adding the next, creating an emulsion that prevents separation during baking. The mixture should fall from your whisk or beater in a smooth ribbon. Fold in the chopped shrimp and shredded cheese using a silicone spatula with a gentle turning motion rather than stirring, preserving the airiness of your mixture while ensuring even distribution.

Step 3: Assemble and Bake to Perfection

Pour your filling into the warm pre-baked crust slowly, starting in the center and moving outward in a spiral pattern. This technique helps avoid overflow and ensures even distribution. Return the assembled pie to the hot cookie sheet in the oven, positioning it in the middle where heat circulation is optimal. Bake for exactly 30-35 minutes, checking at the 25-minute mark - you're looking for a filling that has risen slightly and jiggles only slightly at the center when gently shaken. The top should display an appetizing golden hue with perhaps slightly darker edges.

Step 4: Master the Cooling Process

The 15-minute standing time after baking isn't just a suggestion - it's essential chemistry. During this period, residual heat continues cooking the center while proteins set and flavors meld. Cutting too soon results in a filling that oozes rather than slices cleanly. For picture-perfect slices, use a sharp knife dipped in hot water and wiped clean between cuts. The pie can be served warm or at room temperature, though the flavors are most pronounced when just slightly warmer than room temperature.

Pin it

My grandmother grew up on Florida's Gulf Coast and always said that good shrimp should smell like the ocean, not fishy. She taught me to appreciate seafood from an early age, insisting that fresh shrimp need minimal seasoning to shine. This pie became a staple at our family reunions, where even the inland relatives who claimed not to like seafood would help themselves to generous slices.

The Art of Pairing

This Florida Shrimp Pie pairs beautifully with different sides depending on the season and occasion. A crisp green salad with citrus vinaigrette provides a refreshing contrast to the rich filling, cutting through the creaminess with bright acidity. For heartier appetites, roasted asparagus or sautéed green beans offer textural contrast while complementing the coastal flavors. In summer months, I've served this alongside sliced heirloom tomatoes with just a sprinkle of sea salt, letting their natural sweetness play against the savory pie.

Storage and Reheating Tips

Proper storage ensures this pie remains delicious for days after preparation. If you have leftovers (which rarely happens in my house), allow the pie to cool completely before covering loosely with foil rather than plastic wrap, which can create condensation and soggy crust. Refrigerate for up to three days, but never freeze the baked pie as the texture of both the crust and the shrimp will deteriorate significantly. When reheating, avoid the microwave which creates uneven hot spots and rubbery shrimp. Instead, place individual slices in a 300°F oven for about 10 minutes until just warmed through, protecting the crust edges with small pieces of foil if needed.

Pin it

Customization Options

The beauty of this Florida Shrimp Pie lies in its adaptability to personal preferences and what you have on hand. For a more pronounced flavor profile, try adding a tablespoon of Old Bay seasoning or Cajun spice blend to the filling. Those who enjoy a textural contrast might appreciate the addition of finely diced bell peppers or a handful of sweet corn kernels folded into the mixture. I've even made a luxurious version with the addition of lump crab meat alongside the shrimp for special celebrations. The basic formula remains reliable while welcoming experimentation based on seasonal availability and personal taste preferences.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use fresh shrimp instead of frozen shrimp?

Yes, fresh shrimp can be used as long as they are peeled, deveined, and cooked beforehand. Ensure they are well drained to avoid excess moisture in the filling.

→ What can I substitute for chive-and-onion cream cheese?

You can use plain cream cheese and add finely chopped chives and onions to recreate the flavor.

→ How do I prevent the crust from getting soggy?

Pre-baking the crust until it’s lightly golden helps prevent a soggy bottom. Also, ensure the shrimp is well drained before adding to the filling.

→ Can I make this pie ahead of time?

Yes, you can prepare and bake the pie in advance, then reheat it gently in the oven before serving.

→ What side dishes pair well with shrimp pie?

This pie pairs wonderfully with a crisp green salad, roasted vegetables, or a light soup for a balanced meal.