01 -
Remove steaks from refrigerator, pat dry with paper towels, and season generously with salt and pepper. Allow to come to room temperature.
02 -
Place butter in a microwave-safe bowl covered with wax paper. Soften using lowest defrost setting for 8-second intervals, checking after each interval. Do not melt.
03 -
Smash softened butter with the back of a metal spoon. Peel and finely chop garlic cloves, add to butter.
04 -
Rinse and dry parsley, finely chop the leaves and add to butter mixture. Rinse and dry rosemary, remove leaves from stems, finely chop until you have 1 teaspoon, and add to butter.
05 -
Add paprika and salt to butter mixture. Stir until thoroughly blended and creamy. Use immediately soft or prepare for storage.
06 -
Transfer butter mixture onto parchment paper, wax paper, or plastic wrap. Shape into a log, roll up in the paper, and twist ends to seal. Refrigerate at least 1 hour before slicing.
07 -
Heat an ungreased cast iron or nonstick pan over high heat until very hot. Place steaks in a single layer. Cook first side 3-4 minutes until it releases easily from the pan. Flip with tongs and cook second side 3-4 minutes. Add slices of compound butter during final minute of cooking.
08 -
Trim excess fat from steak edges. Preheat grill covered on high (500°F/260°C) for 10-15 minutes. Clean and lightly oil grates. Sear steaks uncovered 2-3 minutes per side. Reduce heat to medium-high, cover grill, and continue cooking until desired doneness.
09 -
Transfer steaks to a platter, top with compound butter slices, and tent loosely with foil. Rest 5 minutes before serving to allow juices to redistribute and internal temperature to rise slightly.